April 2013
Peer Learning Activity on Early School Leavers
in France
On
the 17-18-19th of April, the European Commission's Early School Leavers (ESL) Thematic Working Group (TWG) along with
the French Ministry of Education organised a Peer Learning Activity (PLA) in
Paris.
The
aim of this meeting was to bring together key stakeholders among which
representatives from EU Member States ministries to share good practices on
tackling ESL. The PLA was to provide additional insights to the development and
implementation of comprehensive policies against early school leaving. Its
conclusions will help finalise the first report of the TWG.
COFACE
attended the PLA, representing best practices, research and policy positions
developed by its national member organisations.
Two
specific topics were addressed during the PLA: the understanding of how cooperation at different levels between
key institutions and stakeholders can be further developed and more information
in relation to second chance education.
The
French Ministry of Education presented its practices in cross-sectoral
cooperation by introducing the Platforms which are responsible for coordinating
the work of the various existing bodies and actors responsible for tackling
ESL. A centralised database
referencing all ESL fuels the Platforms with the names and contact details of
ESL in order to provide a quick and tailored response to their individual
situation and need.
A
visit to second chance education schools enabled participants to exchange with
teachers, students and headmasters to better understand the set-up,
inner-workings and key success factors of such schools, such as strong political
support and exceptionally motivated and dedicated individuals (teachers,
headmasters, often working unpaid overtime).
The
EU Commission will publish the key findings of the PLA in the coming
weeks. COFACE will disseminate
these to its national member organisations to further feed their reflection on
ESL policies.
On January 2011, the European Commission published a
communication on tackling Early School Leaving (ESL), alongside the Council's recommendations on policies to reduce school leaving. ESL is an important issue to COFACE because the family environment is often identified as an important factor determining school achievement. As the Commission and the Council rightly point out, a lower socio-economic background or lower parental educational achievement are amongst the main factors when trying to explain ESL rates.
COFACE welcomes the calls for action and the programme drafted by the Commission and the Council aiming at tackling ESL. Several proposals are noteworthy such as: (1) provision of high-quality early childhood education and care services; (2) systemic language support and support in general for children with a migrant background; (3) active desegregation policy in schools; (4) permeability of educational pathways; (5) increased participation and co-operation of parents; (6) financial support for families conditionally linked to school attendance; and finally, (7) mainstreaming of ESL in all relevant policies at an EU level.
At the same time, COFACE wishes to underline a few shortcomings of these recommendations.
Firstly, the call for mainstreaming of ESL in all EU policies is -up to now at least- simply wishful thinking: the EU has barely advanced on reconciliation of work and family life or made progress on the maternity leave directive, not to mention the issue of paternity leave.
Secondly, when the Council recommends "support and empowerment of teachers" to enhance their competences, this often translates into more burdensome training and responsibilities for teachers without any improvement of their salary or a formal recognition of their increased workload. In many countries, teacher's council meetings or remedial lessons are not considered part of normal "working hours".
Thirdly, extra-curricular activities should not only be developed outside of school (as the Council paper suggests) but also within the school. Indeed, the integration of leisure activities in schools contributes to creating a "positive" image of the school environment and prevents ESL since pupils have more incentives to go to school.
Finally, we note that many other supportive measures need to be targeted at parents, such as Life Long Learning (LLL) programmes or fostering parental participation in social and cultural life. Family organisations contribute to this active participation and LLL by publishing magazines addressing common parenting issues, organising training sessions, discussion groups and other events for parents. Any successful strategy to tackle ESL will first have to support and involve civil society organisation.
print
send
Published on 04 Sep 2011
Updated on 30 Apr 2013
